Look through our alphabetical list of categories

Bagel Shops on Long Island, NY

Updated Oct 05 2014 04:20 PM EST with 76 listings
Many of us like to start our mornings with a bagel, toasted, with or without cream cheese. There are many varieties, but the top five are plain, sesame, poppy, onion and cinnamon raisin. Did you know that bagels are cooked twice? First the raw bagel dough is either hand-formed or machine dropped into a pot of boiling, salted water. This step ensures a smooth, unbroken exterior. Next the bagel is baked to perfection and spilled into a wire basket to evenly cool down to avoid breakage.
Bagel Shops on Long Island, NY

Bagel Biz

Bagel shop catering Melville, NY
360 Walt Whitman Rd. Rt. 110 so of Rt 25, Melville NY 11747 Tel 631-385-1900
Fax: 631-385-2131

Bagel Boss

Toll-Free 888
E-mail: info@bagelboss.com; Website: bagelboss.com

Bagel Boss - Carle Place

43 Old Country Rd., Carle Place NY

Bagel Boss - Commack

bagel shop and premier kosher caterer
10 Mayfair Shopping Center, Commack NY 11725 Mayfair Shopping Center, Fax 631-864-0860
Tel: 631-864-2233

Bagel Boss - East Northport

bagel shop and premier kosher caterer
1941 Jericho Tpk., East Northport NY 11731 Tel 631-462-3922
Fax: 631-462-3924

Bagel Boss - East Norwich

1011 Oyster Bay Rd., East Norwich NY 11732 Tel 516-624-0406
Fax: 516-624-0408

Bagel Boss - Hewlett

1352 Peninsula Blvd., Hewlett NY 11557 Tel 516-569-8600

Bagel Boss - Hicksville

432 South Oyster Bay Rd., Hicksville NY 11801 Staples Plaza, Tel 516-681-1856
Fax: 516-681-5737

Bagel Boss - Merrick

2101 Merrick Rd., Merrick NY 11566 Tel 516-379-2836

Bagel Boss - Oceanside

405 Merrick Rd., Oceanside NY 11572 Tel 516-766-1581

Bagel Boss - Port Washington

900 Port Washington Blvd., Port Washington NY Tel 516-767-1813

Bagel Boss - Roslyn

400 Willis Ave., Roslyn NY 11576 Tel 516-626-5599

Bagel Boys

801 East Jericho Tpk., Huntington Station NY 11746 Tel 631-271-0211
Fax: 631-271-0208; E-mail: SheaDPW@aol.com

Bagel Boyz, The

hot bagels deli and catering in Syosset Long Island free delivery 7 days a week no minimum Dreesen's Famous Donuts made fresh daily on premises
236 West Jericho Tpk., Syosset NY 11791 Tel 516-677-1900
Fax: 516-677-1910

Bagel Buddies Inc

2134 Route 25a., Wading River NY 11792 Tel 631-821-0500

Bagel Buoy Market

3 Bay St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-7690

Bagel Cafe

903 Route 110, Melville NY 11747 Tel 631-271-7108

Bagel Cafe II

Bagel Shop in Bayshore NY which also does breakfast catering
134 W Main Street, Bay Shore NY 11706 Tel 631-666-0195

Bagel Chalet

Commack Long Island New York bagel shop
36 Veterans Memorial Hwy., Commack NY 11725 Tel 631-499-9820
Fax: 631-499-0406; Website: bagelchaletofcommack.com

Bagel Factory, The

255 Airport Plaza Blvd., Farmingdale NY 11791 Airport Plaza, Tel 631-420-5391

Bagel Hut

Bagel shop in Great Neck, NY also offering catering services.
503 Middle Neck Rd., Great Neck NY 11023 Tel 516-482-8939

Bagel King

5 -B Main St., Kings Park NY Tel 631-269-6049

Bagel Lovers Cafe & Deli

136 East Main St., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-727-5080

Bagel Master Corp

43 Cold Spring Rd., Syosset NY 11791 Tel 516-921-9773
Website: bagelmaster.com

Bagel Palace

40 West Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-723-1264
Fax: 631-723-1086

Bagel Shop

65 Main St., Westhampton Beach NY 11978 Tel 631-288-2336

Bagel USA

Huntington Long Island NY Bagel Shop
593 West Jericho Tpk., Huntington NY 11743 Tel 631-271-1353
Fax: 631-271-6170

Bagel Works

Bagels, sandwiches, and wraps
55 Wall St., Huntington Village NY 11743 Tel 631-351-1300

Bagelicious

Freshly baked New York water boiled bagels; catering and bagel gift package available
1864 Front St., East Meadow NY 11554 Tel 516-794-0552
Website: bagelicious.com

Bagelicious Cafe

Bagels, desserts, baked goods, and delis
1031 Route 112, Port Jefferson Station NY 11776 Fax 631-642-3663
Tel: 631-642-0741

Bagelman of Garden City

Bagelman is located in Garden City, NY offering pick up or delivery sandwiches, burgers, bagel dogs, signature sandwiches, three soups daily and catering is avaialble.
664 Franklin Ave., Garden City NY 11530 Tel 516-746-2881
Website: crazyhungry.com

Bagels & A Hole Lot More

2310 Nesconset Hwy., Stony Brook NY 11790 Tel 631-444-0010

Bagels & Brunch

295 Montauk Hwy., Speonk NY 11972 Tel 631-325-0850

Bagels & More

100 South St., Oyster Bay NY 11771 Tel 516-922-2549

Bagels Etc

332 Jericho Tpke., Syosset NY 11791 Tel 516-364-8883

Bagels Your Way

Like the name implies- a wide array of fresh bagels every way you like them.
48 North Rd., Southold NY 11972 Tel 631-765-1642

Better On A Bagel

4960 Nesconset Hwy., Port Jefferson Station NY 11776 Tel 631-473-5858

Daily Bagel Plus

29 Glen St., Glen Cove NY 11542 Tel 516-759-0850

Dee-Licious Bagels Inc

Fresh bagels from the bakery for pick-up, takeout, and special occasions; panini, wraps, salads, smoothies, juices, cakes, cinnamon rolls, and more.
34 South Etna Ave., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-4909

Dix Hills Bagels East

215 Comehlsen Dr., Commack NY 11725 Commack Commons, Tel 631-462-6433

Dreesen's Excelsior Market

This is how doughnuts are supposed to taste-crispy on the outside and soft and airy inside. You can also get deli sandwiches and salads, gourmet grocery itmes, and top-quality meats.
33 Newtown Lane, East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-0465
Website: dreesens.com

Eastport Bagels & Brunch

Homemade muffins & brownies.
587 Montauk Hwy., Eastport NY 11941 Tel 631-325-8410

Elm Street Eatery - Closed

New bagel shop in Huntington Village NY offering large variety of bagels
12 Elm St., Huntington Village NY 11743 Tel 000-000-0000
Tel: 000-000-0001

First Class Bagels

Bagels, salads, hot foods, carving station, grillled sandwiches, bakery items catering for any occasion East Northport Long Island New York
1922 Jericho Tpk., East Northport NY 11731 Elwood Shop. Cntr., Tel 631-462-6013

Four Oaks Gourmet Deli & Bakery

47 Jagger Lane, Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-287-6445

Gabby's Gourmet Bagels - Woodbury

Bagelatessen: wraps, soups, salads, bakery, deli. Gourmet catering.
8025 Jericho Tpk., Woodbury NY 11797 Woodbury Town Plaza, Tel 516-496-9000
Fax: 516-496-1001; Website: gabbysgourmet.com

Gabby's Gourmet Bagels - Woodbury

Bagelatessen: bagels, wraps, salads, omlettes and more plus gourmet catering
408 Jericho Tpke., Woodbury NY 11797 0000 Tel 516-496-3888
Website: gabbysgourmet.com

Goldberg's Famous Bagels - East Hampton

100 Pantigo Rd., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-329-8300

Goldberg's Famous Bagels - Southampton

819 North Hwy., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-204-1046

Gourmet Bagel

107 Walt Whitman Rd. Rt. 110 so of Rt 25, Melville NY 11747 Tel 631-423-8777

Hampton Bagels - East Hampton

252 West Montauk Hwy., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-728-7893

Hampton Bagels - East Hampton

Real, New York bagels for the Hamptons.
74 North Main St., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-5411

Harbourfront Deli & The Loft

A full line of deli specialties including fresh bagels.
48 Front St., Greenport NY 11944 betw 1st & Main St), Tel 631-477-1878

Have-A-Bagel

5980 Jericho Tpk., Commack NY Tel 631-499-0303

House of Bagels

4 Vanderbilt Pkwy., Commack NY 11725 Tel 631-499-9677

K B'S Bread

1 Wagon Wheel Lane, Cutchogue NY 11935 Tel 631-734-7038

Li'l Smitty's Bagel Café

2195 Jericho Tpk., Commack NY 11725 Tel 631-462-4440

Locust Valley Bagelry New York

Locust Valley Long Island NY Bagelry
155 Forest Ave., Locust Valley NY 11560 Tel 516-759-3081

Long Island Bagel Cafe

Long Island's largest selection of homemade salads, cream cheese, bagels and bialys, wraps. Party platters, overstuffed heroes, continental breakfasts.

Long Island Bagel Cafe - Bellmore

550 Jerusalem Ave., Bellmore NY Tel 516-781-6575

Long Island Bagel Cafe - Glen Cove

89 Forrest Ave., Glen Cove NY Tel 516-671-3354

Long Island Bagel Cafe - Long Beach

757 East Park Ave., Long Beach NY Tel 516-432-2582

Long Island Bagel Cafe - Merrick

2035 Merrick Rd, Merrick NY Tel 516-377-7222

Long Island Bagel Cafe - Nesconset

248 Smithtown Blvd., Nesconset NY Tel 631-366-2362

Long Island Bagel Cafe - Oceanside

3452 Long Beach Rd, Oceanside NY

North Fork Bagel

7 Main Rd., Jamesport NY 11947 Tel 631-722-4800

North Fork Bagel Cafe

North Fork Bagel Cafe- Enjoy a Bagel and More in the A & P Shopping Center.
10095 Main Rd., Mattituck NY 11952 Tel 631-298-8521

Old Town Bagel

681 Old Town Rd., Port Jefferson Station NY 11776 Tel 631-331-4270

Plain and Fancy

Fabulous fresh bagels, crullers, sticky buns and scones, rosemary bread. The entrees are equally popular.
136 Main St., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-3199
Tel: 631-725-0976

Prime Bagel Deli

FREE DELIVERY!!---$10MIN ORDER. Homemade Soups, Salads & Wrap Specials Made Fresh Daily. We Take All Competitor's Coupons.
827 Rt 110 so of Rt 25, Huntington Station NY 11747 Across Kohl's Shop. Cntr, Tel 631-271-3071
Fax: 631-271-3072

Signature Bagels

779 Old Country Rd., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-208-8584

Strathmore Bagel Cafe

Bakery and cafe
1550 Old Country Rd., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-369-4400
Fax: 631-369-6400

Stuff A Bagel

No preservatives, catering available
234 Main St., Farmingdale NY 11735 Tel 516-420-4287
Fax: 516-420-9262; Website: stuffabagel.com

Stuff-a-Bagel

682 Larkfield Rd., East Northport NY 11731 Tel 631-462-2884
Fax: 631-462-5515

Twice Upon a Bagel

Bagels and sandwiches.
358 Montauk Hwy., Wainscott NY 11975 Tel 631-537-5553
Fax: 631-537-0642

University Bagels

1253 Melville Rd., Farmingdale NY 11735 Tel 631-249-4981
Bagels are not just for breakfast, anymore! There are extra-large sandwich-sized bagels and some salads now sport thin sliced and crunchy bagel chips instead of croutons. A popular catering offering is a giant bagel sandwich to be shared by as many as 25 people.

The long lines outside bagel shops can perhaps best measure the popularity of bagels on a Sunday morning. Inside the variety can be mind boggling- the old standards, bagels with vegetables, multi-grain, and fruit bagels and even with chocolate chips! Few things in life are as wonderful as a hot, fresh bagel, buttered or with a variety of cream cheese, perhaps topped with a slice of smoked salmon. This is living!